Watching a loved one struggle with decisions they once handled easily can be heartbreaking. Whether it’s a parent forgetting important appointments, an aging relative making questionable financial choices, or a family member unable to communicate their wishes, these moments raise difficult questions. One of the most important: Is guardianship necessary in Illinois? Understanding when guardianship becomes necessary and what alternatives exist helps you protect your loved one while respecting their independence.
This guide explains the signs of incapacity, mental capacity factors courts consider, emergency procedures, contested cases, and how guardianship compares to power of attorney arrangements. Peck Ritchey, LLC has helped Chicago families navigate these complex decisions for over 100 years, with a combined experience in guardianship administration and guardianship litigation.
Understanding Guardianship in Illinois
Guardianship is a court-supervised legal arrangement where a judge appoints someone to make decisions for an adult who cannot make or communicate responsible decisions about their personal care or finances. Illinois law recognizes that some people need protection due to mental deterioration, physical incapacity, mental illness, developmental disability, or substance abuse issues.
Illinois courts establish two main types of guardianship:
- Guardianship of the Person: The guardian makes decisions about personal care, healthcare, living arrangements, and medical treatment
- Guardianship of the Estate: The guardian manages finances, pays bills, protects assets, and handles legal and financial matters
Courts can also establish plenary guardianship (granting all customary powers) or limited guardianship (granting only specific powers that the person cannot exercise). Understanding these distinctions helps families determine the appropriate level of court supervision needed.
Why Choose Peck Ritchey, LLC for Guardianship Matters
Peck Ritchey, LLC brings recognized expertise to guardianship cases throughout Chicago and Illinois. Kerry Peck, the firm’s founding partner, serves as Chair of the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Elder Law, a designation that reflects deep knowledge of elder law and guardianship issues. Four attorneys at Peck Ritchey, LLC appear in The Best Lawyers in America 2025, with three additional attorneys recognized in Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch 2025. The firm earned Tier 1 ranking in Trusts & Estates and Elder Law in Chicago from Best Law Firms 2026 and maintains U.S. News Best Law Firms recognition.
Beyond credentials, Peck Ritchey, LLC demonstrates practical authority through published work. Kerry Peck authored “Don’t Let Dementia Steal Everything” for the American Bar Association, a resource that helps families understand guardianship and elder law planning. The firm’s attorneys handle both guardianship administration and guardianship litigation, meaning they guide families through establishing guardianships and represent clients in contested cases. When you need experienced guidance on guardianship decisions, (312) 201-0900 to schedule a consultation.
Signs Your Loved One May Need Guardianship
Recognizing when someone needs guardianship protection requires attention to behavioral and cognitive changes. Watch for these warning signs:
- Confusion about dates, times, or familiar people
- Inability to manage medications or medical appointments
- Poor financial decisions or vulnerability to scams
- Difficulty communicating needs or preferences
- Unsafe living conditions or neglect of personal hygiene
- Wandering or getting lost in familiar places
- Inability to understand the consequences of decisions
These signs often indicate the mental capacity factors that Illinois courts examine when determining whether guardianship is necessary. If you notice these changes in a loved one, elder law planning can help protect their interests. Early intervention through elder law attorneys may prevent the need for more restrictive guardianship arrangements.
Mental Capacity Factors Courts Consider
Illinois law defines incapacity through specific criteria. A person may need guardianship if they cannot manage their person or estate because of:
- Mental deterioration: Cognitive decline from dementia or Alzheimer’s.
- Physical incapacity: Inability to communicate or care for oneself.
- Mental illness: Conditions that impair judgment.
- Developmental disability: Lifelong conditions affecting adaptive functioning.
Note: While issues like substance abuse or gambling were historically listed separately, modern Illinois law typically addresses these under the categories of mental illness or deterioration if they severely impair decision-making.
A physician must submit a detailed report to the court documenting the person’s condition and inability to manage their affairs. The court may also appoint a guardian ad litem (GAL), an independent advocate to investigate the person’s situation and report findings to the judge. This process ensures guardianship is only established when genuinely necessary and in the person’s best interest. Understanding mental capacity is crucial for determining whether guardianship or alternative arrangements are appropriate.
Emergency Guardianship: When You Need Immediate Protection
Sometimes guardianship cannot wait for the standard court process. Illinois law allows temporary or emergency guardianship when someone faces imminent danger or urgent decisions cannot be delayed.
Emergency guardianship lasts up to 60 days and requires demonstrating an immediate need to the court. Common situations include:
- A parent with dementia refusing necessary medical treatment
- An incapacitated person at risk of financial exploitation
- Urgent decisions needed about residential placement or medical care
The emergency process moves faster than standard guardianship, allowing the court to act quickly. If ongoing guardianship becomes necessary, the temporary arrangement can transition to permanent guardianship through the regular court process. Temporary guardianship provides critical protection during crisis situations.
Contested Guardianship: What to Expect
Not all guardianship cases proceed smoothly. The person for whom guardianship is sought, called the “ward”, has the right to contest the guardianship. Adult children or other family members may also challenge the appointment.
Contested guardianship cases proceed to court hearings where both sides present evidence. The person contesting guardianship can present medical evidence, testimony about their decision-making ability, and arguments about why guardianship is unnecessary. The person seeking guardianship must prove by clear and convincing evidence that guardianship is necessary and in the ward’s best interest.
Legal representation becomes critical in contested cases. An experienced guardianship litigation attorney helps gather medical documentation, prepare witnesses, and present evidence effectively to the court. Guardianship litigation requires specialized knowledge of Illinois probate law and court procedures.
Alternatives to Guardianship: Power of Attorney and Other Options
Guardianship is not always the only option for protecting an incapacitated adult. Before pursuing guardianship, consider whether alternatives might better serve your loved one’s needs.
Power of Attorney (POA) allows a person to voluntarily authorize someone to make financial or healthcare decisions on their behalf. The key advantage: POA preserves the person’s autonomy and dignity by allowing them to choose their representative and define their authority. POA works well when someone recognizes their declining capacity and wants to plan ahead. Durable powers of attorney remain effective even if the principal becomes incapacitated.
However, POA requires the person to have sufficient mental capacity to execute the document and understand what they’re authorizing. If your loved one already lacks capacity, POA is no longer an option—guardianship becomes necessary.
Other alternatives include healthcare proxies (authorizing someone to make medical decisions), HIPAA authorizations (allowing access to medical information), and representative payee arrangements (for Social Security or other benefits). Estate planning documents created while someone has capacity can prevent the need for guardianship later.
Peck Ritchey, LLC helps families compare guardianship with these alternatives. Visit the guardianship administration page to learn more about your options and how each approach protects your loved one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between guardianship of the person and guardianship of the estate?
Guardianship of the person focuses on personal care decisions, where someone lives, medical treatment, and daily care. Guardianship of the estate handles finances, pays bills, manages assets, and protects property. A single guardian can hold both roles, or separate guardians can be appointed. Understanding these distinctions helps determine the appropriate guardianship structure for your situation.
How long does the guardianship process take in Illinois?
Uncontested guardianship typically takes 4-8 weeks from filing to court order. Contested cases may take several months, depending on court schedules and case complexity. Emergency guardianship can be established within 24-72 hours when imminent danger exists.
Can a guardianship be contested after it’s established?
Yes. A ward can petition the court to terminate guardianship if they regain capacity. Family members can also challenge guardianship through legal proceedings if circumstances change or if the guardian is not acting in the ward’s best interest. Guardianship litigation may be necessary to address these disputes.
What are a guardian’s ongoing responsibilities?
Guardians must file written reports with the court describing the ward’s condition and care. Guardians of the estate must file an inventory of assets, maintain separate accounts, and seek court approval for major financial decisions. Accountings are required on the first anniversary of appointment and every three years thereafter under Illinois law. Note: Cook County courts require annual accountings. Guardian representation services can help guardians fulfill these obligations.
Is guardianship the only option for protecting an incapacitated adult?
No. Power of attorney, healthcare proxies, representative payee arrangements, and other tools may provide adequate protection depending on the situation. An attorney can help determine which approach best fits your loved one’s needs. Elder law planning explores all available options.
How much does guardianship cost in Illinois?
Guardianship costs vary based on whether the case is contested, court fees, attorney fees, and physician evaluation costs. Peck Ritchey, LLC discusses costs during your consultation and works with families to understand expenses upfront.
Take the Next Step: Protect Your Loved One
Deciding whether guardianship is necessary requires careful consideration of your loved one’s needs, capacity, and preferences. Peck Ritchey, LLC guides Chicago families through this decision with compassion and legal expertise.
Schedule a free consultation with Peck Ritchey, LLC to discuss your situation. Our attorneys handle guardianship administration and guardianship litigation, meaning we can guide you through establishing guardianship or represent you in contested cases. Contact us or call (312) 201-0900 today.
Learn more about guardianship services at our firm’s guardianship administration page and guardianship litigation page.
Related Posts
- An Introduction and Brief Overview of Legal Guardianship
- Important Questions to Consider When Establishing Guardianship in Chicago
- Understanding Guardianship and Power of Attorney: Which One Do You Need?
- Dementia and Elder Abuse
- Removal of Executors, Guardians, Trustees and Agents Under Power of Attorney